ÄúµÄλÖà Ê×Ò³ ¿´ÊÀ½ç

ÖйúÄܱ»Õ÷·þÂ𣿣¨ÉÏ£© [ÃÀ¹úÍøÌù]

quoraÍøÓÑ£ºÖйúµÄºËÐÄÎÄ»¯ÊÇͨÓÃÐ͵Ä£¬·Ç³£¹ã·ºµÄ£¬ÊÇдµÃºÜºÃµÄMaster Branch£¬Èç¹ûÄãÊìϤgit£¬¾ÍÖªµÀÎÒ˵µÄÊÇʲôÒâ˼ÁË¡£Öйú³¯´úÆðÆðÂäÂ䣬ÎÞÏÞÑ­»·¡£Ã¿Ò»´Îµ±Óг¯´ú±äÈõʱ£¬¾Þ´óµÄÔÖÄÑ¾Í»á±Æ½ü¡£È»ºó·Ö±¼ÀëÎö£¬ËÀÍö£¬Ë¥Èõ£¬×ÔÓÉÄÃÈ¡¡£È»ºóеÄȨÁ¦áÈÆð£¬¾ÝΪ¼ºÓÐ…….

Could China be conquered?

ÖйúÄܱ»Õ÷·þÂ𣿣¨ÉÏ£©

¡¾ÒÔÏÂÊÇÆÀÂÛ²¿·Ý¡¿

Mo Chen, lives in China (1989-present)
Answered 23h ago
China’s core culture is a lot like a very generic, really broad, and really well written Master Branch, if you are familiar with git.
Chinese dynasties rise and fall. It’s the only constnant ¡ª cycles.
Each time the dynasties weakens, great disasters loom.
Then it falls apart, dead, weak, ripe for the taking.
A new power rise, takes it.
Many had tried to write a newer, longer lasting Fork Branch. Some derive it from the Master Branch (Xianbei / Wei), some went their separate way (Mongolians / Yuan).
?
ÖйúµÄºËÐÄÎÄ»¯ÊÇͨÓÃÐ͵Ä£¬·Ç³£¹ã·ºµÄ£¬ÊÇдµÃºÜºÃµÄMaster Branch£¬Èç¹ûÄãÊìϤgit£¬¾ÍÖªµÀÎÒ˵µÄÊÇʲôÒâ˼ÁË¡£
Öйú³¯´úÆðÆðÂäÂ䣬ÎÞÏÞÑ­»·¡£Ã¿Ò»´Îµ±Óг¯´ú±äÈõʱ£¬¾Þ´óµÄÔÖÄÑ¾Í»á±Æ½ü¡£È»ºó·Ö±¼ÀëÎö£¬ËÀÍö£¬Ë¥Èõ£¬×ÔÓÉÄÃÈ¡¡£È»ºóеÄȨÁ¦áÈÆð£¬¾ÝΪ¼ºÓС£
ºÜ¶à³¯´úÏëÒªÊéд¸üиü³¤¾ÃµÄFork Branch¡£ÓÐЩÔòȡ֮ÓÚMaster Branch£¨Ïʱ°/꣩£¬ÓÐЩÔò×ß³ö×Ô¼ºµÄµÀ·£¨ÃɹÅÈË/Ôª³¯£©¡£

The former usually ended up become the master branch itself, the latter short-lived, and only fragments were absorbed into the master branch.
It seems that the Master branch always wins.
This is because how the Chinese Culture Master Branch is defined.
Chinese Culture doesn’t require people to be ¡°Better¡±. It require people to ¡°act appropriately¡±.
It doesn’t question your intentions, as long as your actions are good. ¡°ÂÛ¼£²»ÂÛÐÄ£¬ÂÛÐÄÊÀÉÏÎÞÍêÈË¡£¡± Merit actions not intents; (if we) merit intents this world there won’t be any perfect people left.
But when it’s about people when their abilities are limited by outside world, Chinese culture then tells you: ¡°ÂÛÐIJ»ÂÛ¼££¬ÂÛ¼£º®ÃÅÎÞТ×Ó¡£¡± Merit intent not actions, (if we) merit actions all poor families there will not be filial piety.

ǰÕßͨ³£×îÖÕ»á±ä³Émaster branch£¬ºóÕßÔòºÜ¶ÌÃü£¬Ö»ÓÐË鯬±»ÎüÊÕÈëµ½master branch¡£
Ã²ËÆ×ÜÊÇmaster branchÈ¡µÃ×îÖÕʤÀû¡£ÕâÊÇÓÉÖйúÎÄ»¯µÄMaster BranchµÄ¶¨Ò巽ʽ¾ö¶¨µÄ¡£ÖйúÎÄ»¯²¢²»ÒªÇóÈËÃDZäµÃ¡°¸üºÃ¡±¡£ËüÒªÇóÈËÃÇ¡°Ç¡µ±µÃÌ塱¡£Ö»ÒªÄãµÄÐÐΪÊǺõÄ£¬Ëü¾Í²»»áÖÊÒÉÄãµÄÒâͼ¡£¡°ÂÛ¼£²»ÂÛÐÄ£¬ÂÛÐÄÊÀÉÏÎÞÍêÈË¡£¡±µ«Êǵ±ÈËÃǵÄÄÜÁ¦Êܵ½ÍⲿÊÀ½çµÄÏÞÖÆÊ±£¬ÖйúÎÄ»¯¾Í»á¸æËßÄ㣺¡°ÂÛÐIJ»ÂÛ¼££¬ÂÛ¼£º®ÃÅÎÞТ×Ó¡£¡±

This is not a guideline! This is a contorted debate!
Many had compared Confuciusm to Christianity, but it’s not exactly comparable. If the Bible is a moral compass, Confucius teaching is like a D&D manual ¡ª you need to decide how to use these rules. It is extremely flexible and discusses almost all moral conundrums.
For example, there is a story:
Lu Country has a law: if someone were to pay to ransom Lu citizens unfortunately fallen to become a slave in another country, people can pay the ransom to rescue him/her, the Government will reimburse the rescuer; Zigong (Confucius’ student) paid the ransom and rescured a person, when he came back, he declined the Government’s reimbursement gold. Confucius said: ¡°This is a mistake. From this day onward, No Lu people will ransom slaves from other countries. Accept the ransom reimbursement will not damage your good moral; but declined it, Lu people will no longer be motivated to save their enslaved kins.¡±
Zilu (Another student) saved a drowner, he was grateful that he rewarded Zilu with an Ox, Zilu accepted it. Confucius said: ¡°Lu people will save drowner.¡±

Õâ²»ÊÇÒ»ÖÖÖ¸µ¼·½Õ룡¶øÊÇÒ»ÖÖŤÇúµÄÕù±ç¡£ºÜ¶àÈ˽«Èå¼Ò˼Ïë±È×÷»ù¶½½Ì¾«Éñ£¬µ«ÊǶþÕßûÓпɱÈÐÔ¡£Èç¹û¡¶Ê¥¾­¡·ÊÇÒ»¸öµÀµÂÖ¸ÄÏÕ룬¿××ӽ̵¼¾ÍÊÇÒ»±¾¡¶ÁúÓëµØÏ³ǡ·Êֲᡪ¡ªÄãÒª¾ö¶¨ÈçºÎʹÓÃÕâЩ¹æÔò¡£Ëü·Ç³£µÄÁé»î£¬¼¸ºõÌÖÂÛÁËËùÓеĵÀµÂÄÑÌâ¡£¾Ù¸öÀý×Ó£¬ÓÐÒ»Ôò¹ÊÊÂÊÇÕâÑùµÄ£º
³¹úÖ®·¨£¬Â³ÈËΪÈ˳¼æªÓÚÖîºî£¬ÓÐÄÜÊêÖ®Õߣ¬È¡Æä½ðÓÚ¸®¡£×Ó¹±Êê³ÈËÓÚÖîºî£¬À´¶øÈ㬲»È¡Æä½ð¡£¿××ÓÔ»£º¡°´Íʧ֮ÒÓ¡£×Ô½ñÒÔÍù£¬Â³È˲»ÊêÈËÒÓ¡£È¡Æä½ðÔòÎÞËðÓÚÐУ¬²»È¡Æä½ðÔò²»¸´ÊêÈËÒÓ¡£¡±
×Ó·ÕüÄçÕߣ¬ÆäÈ˰ÝÖ®ÒÔÅ££¬×Ó·ÊÜÖ®¡£¿××ÓÔ»£º¡°Â³È˱ØÕüÄçÕßÒÓ¡£¡±¿××Ó¼ûÖ®ÒÔϸ£¬¹Û»¯Ô¶Ò²¡£
Òâ˼ÊÇ£ºÂ³¹úÓй涨£¬ÊêÂòÔÚ¹úÍ⵱ūÁ¥µÄ³¹úÈË£¬·ÑÓÿÉÒÔ±¨Ïú¡£×Ó¹±·Ç³£ÓÐÇ®£¬ÊêÂò³¹úÈËÈ´²»È¥±¨Ïú£¬×ÔÒÔΪÊÇÒå¾Ù£¬¿××ÓÖªµÀºóÈ´Ö¸³ö×Ó¹±µÄ×ö·¨»áʹÕâÏîÕþ²ßÎÞ·¨¼ÌÐøÏÂÈ¥£¬ÒòΪ²»ÊÇÿ¸öÈ˶¼Ïñ×Ó¹±ÄÇÑùÓÐÇ®£¬¿ÉÒԳе£ÕâÒ»±Ê·ÑÓ㬵«ÊÇÿ¸öÈËÈ´¶¼ÓÐÐß³ÜÖ®ÐÄ£¬ÓÐ×Ó¹±µÄÐÐΪÏÈÔÚ£¬ºóÃæµÄÈ˾ͻá³ÜÓÚÏòÖîºî±¨Ïú»¨·Ñ£¬ÕâÑùÔ¸ÒâΪ³¹úÊêÂòÅ«Á¥µÄÈ˾ͻáÔ½À´Ô½ÉÙ¡£¹ûȻʱ¼äÒ»³¤£¬ÈËÃǶÔÔÚ¹úÍ⵱ūÁ¥µÄ³¹úÈ˾Ͳ»ÎŲ»ÎÊÁË¡£
(ÓÖÓÐÒ»Ìì),×Ó·¾ÈÆðÒ»ÃûÂäË®Õߣ¬ÄÇÈ˸ÐлËû£¬ËÍÁËһͷţ£¬×Ó·ÊÕÏÂÁË¡£¿××Ó¸ßÐ˵ØËµ£º¡°£¨ÕâÏÂ×Ó£©Â³¹úÈËÒ»¶¨»áÓÂÓÚ¾ÈÂäË®ÕßÁË¡£¡±

So, yeah¡­. the Chinese culture moral compass is really open to debate, it’s not settled.
That’s what baffled the stream of conquers of China.
On surface, a Chinese person fears death, we pursue long life. It seems to be an intuitive conclusion that ¡°violence and threat of death can break China.¡±
But when they invade, there are always the bunch of idiots that face death with a smile.
On surface, a Chinese person hates the Government, we think very little of it. It’s not entirely unreasonable to think ¡°If we push the Government just a little, it will collapse and we can conquer China in 3 months.¡±
But when they invade, they find obstinate one man army commander against 200 IJA + Fake IJA death squad, outgunned, outnumbered, but declined request for surrender and fought until his last breath, last ration, and last bullet in the frozen tundra of Manchuria.
There is a certain duality in the Chinese culture. One extremely soft and malleable; one extremely obstinate and unchanging. They work like calcium and phosphate in bones, both making it strong and difficult to conquer.
China can absolutely be conquered.
Over all of our dead bodies.

ËùÒÔÖйúÎÄ»¯µÄµÀµÂÖ¸ÄÏÕëÊÇ¿ÉÒÔÕù±çµÄ£¬Áé»îµÄ£¬¶ø²»Êǹ̶¨²»±äµÄ¡£ËùÒÔÕâÈÃһϵÁеÄÕ÷·þÖйúµÄÈ˸е½ÃԻ󲻽⡣
±íÃæÉÏ£¬ÖйúÈËÅÂËÀ£¬ÎÒÃÇ×·Çó³¤Ãü°ÙËê¡£ËùÒÔ¸øÈ˵ĸоõ¾ÍÊÇ¡°±©Á¦ºÍËÀÍöÍþв¿ÉÒÔ»ÙÃðÖйú¡£¡±µ«Êǵ±ËûÃÇÇÖÂÔʱ£¬×ÜÊÇÓöµ½Ò»ÈºÊÓËÀÈç¹éµÄÈË¡£
±íÃæÉÏ£¬ÖйúÈËÌÖÑáÕþ¸®£¬¸ù±¾²»·ÅÔÚÑÛÀï¡£ËùÒÔÈÕ±¾ÈËÈÏΪÈý¸öÔÂÖ®ÄÚ¾ÍÄÜÕ÷·þÖйú¡£µ«Êǵ±ËûÃÇÇÖÂÔÖйúʱ£¬È´·¢ÏÖÒ»¸öÍçÇ¿µÄ¾ü³¤¿ÉÒÔ¶Ô¸¶200¸öÈÕ¾üºÍα¾ü£¬ËäÈ»ÈËÊýºÍ×°±¸É϶¼²»¼°¶ÔÊÖ£¬µ«ÊÇËû¾Ü¾øÍ¶½µ£¬ÔÚ¶«±±¶³Ô­ÉÏÕ½¶·µ½ËÀ¡£
ÖйúÎÄ»¯Àï´æÔÚ×ÅijÖÖ¶þÔªÐÔ¡£Ò»¸öÊǷdz£µÄÈáÈíºÍ¿ÉËÜ£»ÁíÒ»¸öÊǷdz£µÄÍçÇ¿ºÍ²»±ä¡£ËûÃǾÍÏñ¹ÇÍ·ÀïµÄ¸ÆºÍÁ×ËáÑΣ¬ÈÃ×Ô¼º±äµÃÄÑÒÔÕ÷·þ¡£Öйú¾ø¶ÔÊÇ¿ÉÒÔ±»Õ÷·þµÄ£¬ÄǾÍÊǰÑÎÒÃÇȫɱËÀ¡£

Samuel Xie, lived in China
Answered 14h ago
Mongols tried to conquer China.
They succeeded¡­at first.
Then they became Chinese.
The Manchus gave it another shot.
They became Chinese too.
You can¡¯t conquer a country if you become part of that country.

ÃɹÅÏëÒªÕ÷·þÖйú£¬³É¹¦ÁË£¬µ«ÊǺóÀ´ËûÃÇ×Ô¼º±ä³ÉÁËÖйúÈË¡£Âú×åÈËÒ²ÏëÕ÷·þÖйú£¬ºóÀ´ËûÃÇ×Ô¼ºÒ²±ä³ÉÁËÖйúÈË¡£Èç¹ûÄã±ä³ÉÁËÄǸö¹ú¼ÒµÄÒ»²¿·Ö£¬ÄÇôÄãÊÇÎÞ·¨Õ÷·þËüµÄ¡£

¹ØÓÚ×÷Õß: admin

ÈÈÃÅÎÄÕÂ

·¢±íÆÀÂÛ

µç×ÓÓʼþµØÖ·²»»á±»¹«¿ª¡£ ±ØÌîÏîÒÑÓÃ*±ê×¢